#Bones is cool
5 messages in this thread
I just downloaded bones and did a quick test with it, it is really cool. I
showed it our two animators and they loved it. It looks like the combination of
using it with IK could make for some really fun animations. We've got a few
cool ideas for it already.
Thanks a lot.
Yann Bertaud
Marketing Support, Autodesk.
I do not want to damper the enjoyment of the new Bones Ipazs. But
real Bones should NOT have morph targets. Lightwave Imagine Wavefront and
others have "SMARTSKIN". Morph targets are not bones! Ipaz people, we
need SMARTSKIN!
I think Mr. Munkeby would concur.
Hello Mr. Cyberdreams?, (Do cybers dream of rendered sheep?)
Mr. Munkeby does indeed agree!! As anyone who has messed with the '57
Chevy project is no doubt aware. This method uses huge amounts of resources.
THERFORE, I planned an AXP version. As mentioned in the documentation, I
intend to ship this to anyone who sends in the $$$. I have not actually used
"SMARTSKIN". (If you would care to donate an SGI. . .) Anyway, an AXP
version would generate the mesh at render time. This would take much less disk
space, and might even make up for the execution time by reducing swapping.
I also thought I would mention some thoughts on the topic of AXP vs. Morph
Targets (If you are getting bored, feel free to tune out the rest.):
AXP: Faster (probably), Smaller (definatly), won't motion blur (AXP's just
don't), you can't see where the stuff is in the keyframer. (Yes, you can see
the bones, but it's just not the same.)
Morph Targets: Easier to use (maybe), motion blurs (we sometimes care), I
didn't think the resource drain would be so bad (oops!)
Just different: Morph targets sometimes change shape as parts turn, AXP's
follow the bones better. (Usually, not critical.)
So which should we have to do our work? Everybody votes for . . . BOTH. Ok, no
problem.
P.S. If you really did not like it, I will cheerfully refund the purchase
price. . . <g>
Thanks for the excellent comments. If you would care to send me details of
"SMARTSKIN" style enhancements that you would like I will see what I can do.
No promises. I love coding, but occasionally I need to sleep.
Joe
You have made my DAY! look for my check in the mail.
Hello Mr. Bertaud,
Glad you liked it! I have been hoping someone would try out IK with bones,
as I don't yet have V4. (And, you have all seen my pitiful animation talent
with the dancing Chevy.) I would love to see the results.
Joe