#Video Capture Hardware
3 messages in this thread
In the next few days, I need to have specd out some hardware. The joy is that
we have about $4700 to spend. The agony is that it must be this week and
satisfy four faculty members. This is a machine that will be shared by faculty
and some students, so that they may start experimenting with and learning about
multimedia. This message will be lengthy because I will try to give background
and potential uses. Below are also listed some capabilities that have been
agreed upon, but nothing is cast in stone.
These faculty are all computer users, teaching courses in spreadsheets, word
processing, desktop publishing, business computer graphics, and other
traditional non-programming computer topics. All use presentation software and
some are learning Authorware. All are interested in exploring the
possibilities of sound and video. This machine will be used for the next 6 –
12 months for tinkering and for classroom presentation. All of the faculty are
in the Business Division, and use PCs with DOS/Windows. The machine will be
attached to a Netware 3.12 network with plenty of storage space available.
Development and playback will be primarily Authorware and Powerpoint, with some
C++/MCI programming.
Each of the following is open to discussion:
Capabilities:
Moving Video Capture
Single Frame Capture
Sound Capture
Overlay and RF playback
Dollars ($4700) can be traded up or down for various components, such as
Pentium 60 or 90, 2x or 4x CDRom, 15" or 17" monitor. Our big unknowns are
related to the video capture and playback. The capabilities are listed above
according to priority. What video input/output options will provide the most
bang for our buck?
How much ram? 16 meg?
Is 540meg hard drive enough or more than we need?
Should the sound, cd, and hd all be SCSI?
And again video in and out?
Any help, suggestions or information will be greatly appreciated. Specific
manufacturers, model numbers, and specs for the video components as well as
approximate prices would be great. Any comments regarding bundled software
would also be helpful.
Thanks – Mike
I recently set up a 90mhz Pentium with a Miro DC1 TV motion video capture card
(30fps, ISA card, VHS quality output). Very inexpensive card (under $700.00
thru discounters) but very adaquate output if (and only if) you have a fast
disk sub-system. I'm using WFW 3.11 with Adaptec PCI SCSI adapter and
Micropolis 1760 LT (it's the external model of the 2217 which is mentioned
frequently in reviews). It's very very important to have 32 bit disk and file
access and to have PCI based disk controllers. Once I finally got the correct
drivers installed, which was a major headache, the PCI Adaptec/Micropolis
system really smokes! The Adaptec 32bit drivers more than doubled my disk
throughput.
I considered several other systems including the Targa 2000+ which is clearly
higher quality than the Miro but it costs around $5,000, and requires EISA
based system.
No matter what you use for capture – stick with Adobe Premiere 4.0 for DTV
editing. If you have a fast system, Premiere is wonderful (even with all the
bugs…er features).
Mike,
Here is my two cents:
Capabilities:
Moving Video Capture: Intel Smart Video Recorder Pro, ~$500.00. See review in
this month's Multimedia World magazine. Go Intel for more info. Bundled
software is a good start. Also would get hold of the Multimedia Jumpstart CD
from Microsoft for the latest version of VidEdit for basic video clip editing.
You can request the Jumpstart CD by sending a request to
INTERNET:mmdinfo@microsoft.com with name and address, no charge. The next step
up for video editing would be Adobe Premier for Windows, but try the bundled
and Jumpstart tools first.
Single Frame Capture: Same Intel card will do a good job. If you need still
capture and you don't want/have a video camera available, I like the Apple
QuickTake digital color camera with the Windows connection kit. Does nice
medium res. color stills and does NOT require a capture card. ~$700.00.
Sound Capture: Try the sound card bundled with your machine first, if you have
problems, use good major brand sound card, e.g., SoundBlaster 32 AWE.
Overlay and RF playback: See comments below.
How much ram? 16 meg?: I'd go with 24 meg. minimum, 32 better.
Is 540meg hard drive enough or more than we need?: NO! 1 gig min. to capture
and compress video.
Should the sound, cd, and hd all be SCSI?: Not necessarily. For example,
Enhanced IDE should be fine for a single large hard drive or two. CD may need
to be on sep. SCSI for best performance anyway, hence, an Enhanced IDE HD +
SCSI CD is a good combo. Having all on the same SCSI won't hurt either unless
you plan to record to CD, then, having the CD Recorder and Hard drive on sep.
controllers is a good idea.
And again video in and out?: You'll have fine video capture and playback on the
computer monitor with the Intel SVRP. Do you need output to tape or a TV? If
so, others will have to comment, though maybe something simple like the
Presenter Plus Sound by Consumer Technologies Northwest (800-356-3921) will do
the trick. It outputs to TV and Tape and can be connected to a laptop or
desktop PC. List is $495 and it is bundled with Compel, a Multimedia
Presentation program that is worth a look.
Let's take a base example of a Gateway (this is not an ad for Gateway, just a
concrete example, substitute any other brand as needed) and see what we can do
in your $4700 price range:
Start with the Gateway P5-75 for $2399.
FEATURES*
. Intel 75MHz Pentium microprocessor
. AT case with 145-watt power supply
. 256KB SRAM cache
. 16MB DRAM (70ns SIMMS) expandable to 128MB
. 1.44MB 3.5" diskette drive
. Quad-speed CD-ROM drive
. 730MB Western Digital IDE (10ms) 17MB DTR
with 128K multi-segmented cache buffer
. PCI Enhanced IDE interface
. PCI Local Bus graphics accelerator with 1MB DRAM
. 15" Vivitron color monitor, up to
1280 x 1024 non-interlaced resolution
. AMI BIOS
. Clock/calendar
. 4 16-bit ISA slots, 2 32-bit PCI & 1 PCI/ISA slots
. 124-key AnyKey programmable keyboard
. DOS 6.22/Microsoft Windows For WorkGroups 3.11
. MS mouse version 9.01 & Gateway mouse pad
. QAPlus hardware diagnostics software
. MS Office Pro on CD 4.3, Bookshelf `94 and
Money 3.0
. Fully FCC Certified
. 3 Year Parts, 1 Year Service
Extended Warranty
Add:
Intel SVRP $500
Presenter Plus Sound $500
Upgrade Gateway at time of order as follows:
1 GB Western Digital IDE drive…………………add: $120
17" Vivitron color monitor…………………….add: $260
Wavetable audio kits
Ensoniq Soundscape & Altec ACS-31…………..add: $209
PCI local-bus graphics accelerator
with 2MB VRAM…………………………….add: $150
+8 meg RAM…………………………………..add: $400
—————————————————sub: $1089
Net, ~$4500 to get a 75 MHz Pentium with 24 meg RAM, 1 gig hard drive, 17"
monitor, 2 meg VRAM, a 4X CD, the Intel SVRP, and the Presenter for TV/Tape
output. You could get similar configs from Micron, Zeos, etc. You would have
to give quite a bit in processor speed to go with someone like Compaq at the
same price, but then you would get their excellent service. Sounds like those
involved in your project are computer savvy, though, so one of the mail order
folks might be fine. Use their forums on CIS for help, it is faster than
calling <wry grin>!
Hope this is helpful. Regards, Robb.