#ACAD/AEC
16-Apr-88 10:39:02
Sb: #21833-#ACAD/AEC
Fm: Craig Sharp [Mem TM] 73417,2320
To: Cliff Gauntlett [ADESK] 76310,304
.All of the work can be done from screen menus. Great for a 19" monitor,
probably not useable on a 12". Some menus were hard to read even on the
19".
.
.3d package left ACAD in the dust. It is impressive to Architects, until
they try to get a client to pay for it, and the time it takes to work and
design in 3d is not worth it, unless the user can't visualize what he is
doing in 2d. Automatic elevation creation from the 3d element plan was
most impressive. ARRIS is definitely more slanted toward the designer
rather than the production user. It is interesting to note that designers
are the guys doing the buying in the Architecture business.
.
Total package integration (i.e. work from within the drawing for any and
all tasks within or without) and switching between modules was VERY well
done. No acad comment required, I think.
.
.ARRIS is not a production package, as far as I can see. The number of
command options would require total recall memory or the use of their
multitude of menus. Nice, but time consuming.
.
.Variety of window shapes was nice. Due to non edit but visible layers,
other ACAD edit tools, like crossing, weren't required.
.
.All commands worked transparently, from any viewpoint!
.
.Their dimensioning methodology was focused to the Architect, but had
other problems. The perfect solution would be a combination of yours and
theirs.
.
.No dragging for moves and copies. BAD feature. No highlighting and
selection set capability, with add or remove. BAD feature. Blocks could be
dragged in, however.
.
.Hardware lock included. Definitely a bad feature. No site licensing, just
like you guys. A shared BAD feature. I have always felt that the lack of
site licensing promotes pirating. I think one of today's social axioms is
"I don't mind being legal, if it doesn't cost too much!" I'm not saying I
agree, just addressing reality.
.
.ALL programming code is accessible. WOW, I could fix the dimensioning
myself. All I have to do is become a programmer!.
.
.Enough said for now. Could I be one of those guys who previews new
releases for comment? I'd love it.
.
.Craig.
.
..