#What should HELP do?
10-Apr-89 00:48:30
Sb: #43341-#What should HELP do?
Fm: Dave Love 75126,2223
To: John Draper 76703,4322
Larry,
I think the main problem with the HELP key / mouse pointer relationship
is in the loss of keyboard autonomy. I personally hate programs which FORCE me
to use the mouse when it's not strictly necessary. If I am typing away in my
word-processor and forget how to use the spelling checker, I don't want to have
to move my hand to the mouse just so I can position the pointer directly over
the already active cursor.
The other problem I see is that you may be risking major confusion for new
users (not to mention the old-hands :-)). As the system software stands right
now, all keyboard activity is handled by the currently active window. That in
itself is enough to confuse most new users (You mean if I click a CLI to the
background it becomes active? Even I find that infuriating!). To have to
explain to them that, unlike every other key, the HELP key is not tied to the
active window but to the mouse pointer may be too much.
– Dave