S-VHS surprise
25-May-89 02:18:33
Sb: #49760-S-VHS surprise
Fm: Jeff Wilbourn 76657,2454
To: Don Curtis/SYSOP 76703,4321
I have no idea if that has any bearing on a valid comparison between the 2
technologies. Comparing 2 alternate technologies almost always involves apples
and oranges, and I'm not interested in a "which is better" discussion anyway.
However, I would like to point out using a 2-head deck as a VHS yardstick isn't
particularly fair to it, as they have had 4-head decks as long as they have had
multiple speeds, and the original "SP" 2-head decks only had the better heads.
A valid point could be made that the vast majority of decks in service are
2-heads so it's representative, but it's still not a good yardstick.
To give you (or anybody else) an idea of the difference between the 2, not long
after I got my original deck I did a side-by-side comparison between my deck
and my brother-in-law's 4-head VHS deck. This was even before Dolby stereo
sound, much less HQ, digital enhancement, Hi-Fi, and anything else they've
tacked on so it's a valid comparison. The EP speeds were almost identical, too
close to call. But, you're familiar with increase of quality in going from EP
to SP on a 2-head deck? The improvement of his 4-head's SP over my 2-head's SP
was at least that. Not very scientific, I admit, but everybody there agreed to
that description. Even me, and I was hoping for a less marked difference.