#What Should I Buy??
19-May-93 03:39:39
Sb: #48651-#What Should I Buy??
Fm: Jack L. Chalker 72205,613
To: Brian Rodeck 75250,3337
Okay, as I currently have a SCSI-based EISA system with not one but two,
count 'em TWO, SCSI-2 EISA controllers installed, I think I can answer your
questions here.
16 bit is always better than 8 bit because it doubles the data path. It
won't make your CD ROM work any faster but it WILL give better throughput
because more data can be transferred at one time. While EISA SCSI-2 is the
fastest by far, it so far exceeds the mechanical abilities of not only the
fastest CD ROM player today but probably for a few years to come that you will
not notice nearly the speed increase that you would just going from 8 to 16
bit. The bus is slightly faster than the standard bus but the CD can't feed
information through much faster because it's already feeding at the speed at
which it can read. The real joy of an SCSI-2 EISA card, well done, is when you
stick a SCSI-2 hard disk on it. Faster than local bus. Faster than a speeding
bullet…well, okay. But it's as close to instantaneous as your CPU and your
own personal real time clock can come.
Other peripherals benefit in various ways depending on mechanical speeds as
well. My Panasonic magneto-optical rewritable disk drive is only slightly
faster when writing (the head speed again) but 2.5 times as fast on a read, and
my scanner went from 380Kb/s transfer speed to 1200Kb/s transfer speed, which
is as fast as the arm can make a pass over the original, digitize the info, and
send it. Faster, actually. Certainly sped up scanning of even 24 bit true color
originals, though.
Best EISA SCSI-2 board on performance/price: BusLogic 742A. It works as
advertised, is long-term supported (MicroSoft has BusLogic doing its built-in
ASPI drivers for NT), and is fully ASPI compliant so it'll support and work
with just about all the other peripherals now coming out.
Best 16 bit: not nearly as easy. Adaptec's 154X series, Ultrastor, Future
Domain, you name it, all have solid performers. Just make sure BEFORE YOU BUY
that the board in question supports the ASPI standard. Some don't (IBM's for
one!).
Best driver pack: CorelSCSI–$79, run-once, update when you add stuff, and
it drives most stuff out there.
Fastest CD ROM of the moment: Pioneer's 600XA 6 disk mini-changer with 600
speed, available ONLY as a changer, though, at like $1300. It, Toshibas, and
others are all fast. Get a 300 speed (multispin) unit that is XA compliant
(spend the little extra–it is worth it). NEC is solid but doesn't upgrade its
stuff. Toshiba offers firmware upgrades when new stuff comes out and I like my
Toshiba a lot.
Enough?