3/4" vs. svhs system
15-Jun-92 00:22:17
Sb: #17132-3/4" vs. svhs system
Fm: Ken Loss-Cutler 76106,3416
To: ROBERTO LACAYO 70410,2731
Roberto:
3/4" will continue to be a used format for industrial/corporate work
for the foreseeable future BUT it is being phased out of production.
The major manufacturers have already discontinued the 3/4" format.
3/4" SP was an attempt to revamp the format but it was short-lived.
BetaSP has become the mid-range defacto standard for animation
recording, but S-VHS is holding its own. The 7750 lists for around
6K, about half the price of the low-end BetaSP option. For most
applications, the S-VHS is quite sufficient, but if you plan on doing
work for broadcast clients (and that includes "cheap" car commercials
and the like) you will probably be well-advised to bite the bullet
and purchase the BetaSP. If corporate, however, is your main goal,
go with the S-VHS. I just don't see where 3/4" is a viable option
except for motion testing and the like, given the cost/benefit
options available with the other formats. All these arguements will
become academic in a matter of a few years, anyway, when direct
RGB-analog recording to laserdisc or even directly to computer drives
becomes more nearly perfected and the price begins to come down. It
is, however, a safe bet that you can recoup the cost of your tape
deck over the next 2-3 years before that occurs. I feel sorry,
though, for the animators who have to make this choice a couple of
years from now. It will be a tough one. Good Luck, and let us know
how things turn out.
Ken Loss-Cutler