Keyboards and Icons
01-Jul-88 20:10:17
Sb: #132706-Keyboards and Icons
Fm: Richard Rae/SYSOP 76703,4253
To: Don Curtis/SYSOP 76703,4321
Now wait just a minute here.
First of all, you congratulated ONE person who "proved your point" about the
folded corner. I don't know how that proves your point when as many if not
more people have already said "duh". I'll add another "duh" to that… I had
absolutely NO idea what your icon was supposed to represent. And that on top
of the fact that I happen to USE a 3270 on a regular basis. Harumph… don't
get me started on 3270 icons. Want to explain to me how the little Ben
Franklin eyeglasses is intuitive for "printer"? Or what the little circle
with the slash through it means? Or any other of those half dozen other
silly symbols in the status bar that mean _nothing_?
If, and I repeat *IF*, an icon is obvious to everyone, it might be a better
approach, but that is not the case with your <-| and ->| symbols. I maintain
that a key marked RETURN or TAB is _just_ as "understandable after one use".
Because it's what it DOES, not the symbol or word, that makes the connection.
Look, let's leave non-English speaking people out of this for a bit. I
seriously doubt you'd expect to be able to sit down at a Chinese or French
computer and use it. What does it matter if the RETURN key says <-| instead
of whatever the heck RETURN is in Chinese or French? You ALREADY know what
the key does and where it is because of the standard placement; really, the
RETURN key doesn't need any marks on it at all. But okay, you can find the
RETURN… but how do you intend to deal with MS-DOS or AmigaDOS or whatever
<continued>