#CD-I VS. CDTV
10-Aug-92 09:41:50
Sb: #26627-#CD-I VS. CDTV
Fm: Kevin Darling 76703,4227
To: Fernando Cassia 73000,106
Greetings Fernando,
Sir, I hope you're not just naively repeating what Commodore President
Dionne said in his deliberately misleading letter in the final issue of
INFO magazine. So far, it sounds like you have been. Please correct me if
you aren't.
CD-I isn't any more proprietary than CD-DA or CD-ROM is. Anyone can
license it (and every major manufacturer has) and build their own CD-I
players.
CD-I also isn't CD-ROM. CD-I is a new derivative of the Compact Disc
standard, just as CD-ROM is a derivative of CD-DA. CD-ROM file standards
need not apply to CD-I, any more than such file standards would apply to
CD-DA.
As for MIDI, adapters were shown last year. Yamaha says their player will
include it. Most players (even current ones) also have ports which can be
used for keyboards and printers.
How is the sound "better" on CDTV? Here again, I think you're just
repeating what you've read without bothering to find out any details. I
admire informed enthusiasm for anything, including CDTV… but blind
fanaticism has always bothered me.
regards – kevin