CompuServe Messages

Joe, "REAL" architecture – ouuch!, ooooh!, ouch! Just because one doesn't put AIA after one's name does not mean that one is not an architect <g> – our chapter here is very poor and it's just too expensive to belong for only the magazine. Of course I create Architecture (both in mesh and concrete) and one can create very intricate, delicate forms without solid modeling. Obviously this is all a matter of choice and what works best for whomever – we'd probably learn a lot from looking over eachother's shoulder for an afternoon. I've created all the forms you spoke of (intersecting barrel vaults, groin vaults, elliptical ceilings, fluted columns, etc) without solid modeling – modeling the control points/arcs/plines and using them to generate AutoCAD meshes and 3DS lofts (these control entities can be used by repeated forms for numurous tasks). When you combine custom LISP with basic AutoCAD you can do a lot of quick modeling (granted you don't know how much it weighs but who really cares <g>). Even if I am forced to do the perverbial decorated shed I usually include some sophisticated form/detail somewhere if only to keep my sanity and self-respect. My analogy to cardboard was an analogy to how most architects build their study (or finish) models – very few will carve into solid blocks of wood or plastic – a little tough on the interiors <g>. I agree with you on using AutoCAD – any of our given projects will use 80-98% ACAD models and will always be kept current as a DWG. The key for using the Lofter is to use DXF paths that you create and align in AutoCAD – say the centerlines of walls and sections. This can make even the most complicated form a snap – just did a surpentine 3-story wall section yesterday with the wall section (mullions, drip edges, rounded details, etc.) created in AutoCAD from the SD document and lofted along the curving centerlines in about 15 minutes. Auto Link – it's dead (and was never very useful IMHO). AutoVision holds a little more promise (although it discards a LOT of 3DS3 info). -Phil (RA)