public land collecting
11-Jan-95 15:21:50
Sb: #162483-public land collecting
Fm: Ben Williams 74774,3106
To: christopher . visc 75464,27
Chris,
I'm not clear, here:
> I am an earth science teacher and I spend quite a lot of time collecting
samples for my classes.
> If you are not already aware, this is bill proposed in Congress that would
prohibit all collecting
> on public lands except to what amounts to an elite group of academics.
My understanding is the above is the _current_ situation: Not a proposed
situation. Rules stating the penalties for collecting are posted within ten
miles of my home by the feds.
> This month a new bill is
> close to being introduced: Paleontological Resources Preservation Act of
1995. It would in effect,
> permit teachers and students and anyone interested in rocks, fossils and
minerals to do surface
> collecting. The main reasoning is that weathering and erosion would destroy
surface samples
> anyway, and we all know how important amateurs are in discovering new
samples.
Ok, this is great – it contradicts what you said initially, though… two
different bills?
> The target date for this legislation is late January 1995, and letters to the
Honorable Larry Craig
> (R-ID) and Edward Kennedy (D-MA) requesting their support as Senate Prime
Sponsors of the Act
> are urgently needed from the academic community.
Um, this is for the second one, right? The one that _allows_ collecting,
instead of _disallowing_ it?
> If you support the new Act, please let your own Senate and House members
know. I know that
> for myself, my career in geology began as a little kid prospecting around
picking bits and pieces of
> the past that fueled my curiosity.
I would absolutely support a bill to allow collecting by non professionals –
the current situation is distressingly short-sighted, and for exactly the
reason described above. I have personally seen huge bones erode out of the
shore of Fort Peck Lake and be destroyed by the surf – smashed against the
rocks – simply because there were "more important" collecting sites for the
academics and we, lay people, were forbidden – on truly serious penalty – to
save the specimens ourselves. Many other instances come to mind, but none as
heart-rending.
Ben Williams