#Graphic Card Review
25-Nov-91 21:42:37
Sb: #21838-#Graphic Card Review
Fm: Kenneth Elliott [CAM TM] 73737,2054
To: Off Broadway 74435,16
Robert,
I agree that benchmarks such as GRPERF are wonderful to diagnose peformance
of drivers and cards. Your 0 width polyline example is a good one. As you
noted, you would not have found this problem without your test. Doesn't this
reflect how little the user notices such things? I don't view a graphics
card a something that *helps* to get things done, but rather something that
gets in the way. If I have to wait for *anything* during the design phase,
the computer is getting in the way. A good board is one that doesn't cause
me to wait on it. So, if the board draws 0 width plines slow, thats ok, as
long as it gets finished before I'm ready.
The biggest problem I have with benchmarks is they hurt a productive tool
which might be 'fast enough' while helping a faster, but poorly implemented
product.
I'm rather PO'ed at one board maker that promised a slow menu system on a
beta I tested was already fixed. Later, I discovered they failed to fix
the shipping software. I would have burned them on the review, but now its
too late. So, an end user might decide I'm a real jerk because I didn't
mention the slow menu system. Or worse. Does this happen to you or did they
just single me out….<g>
Ken <getting a *little* smarter every day> ///