Ask a USGS geologist
04-Dec-94 23:30:51
Sb: #156609-Ask a USGS geologist
Fm: Doug Mitchell 70621,702
To: Lanny R. Ream 73512,1163
Hi, Lanny–
Simply the fact that DeLorme maps are on CD in ordinary stores makes them a
vast improvement over the USGS data they are based on, from the viewpoint of
who they are aimed at, computer-age drivers. The market for full-detail topo
quad maps on CD should be growing fast enough (since it includes general
hikers) that these will soon appear (if they have not already) from private
enterprises.
Geological maps, on the other hand… They would be immensely more valuable as
vector graphics on CD with links available for GPS systems and other kinds of
software (remember that "wish list" database of sites with coordinates that
would link to the map?), but I do not know if there is enough of a market for
this to happen any time soon.
I suspect you regard the USGS as immune to privatization because of the value
of its contributions to society. But to determine its fate, you need to count
votes and perceptions, not just reasons. Lots of Congresspeople must be
figuring that the last election means there are lots of votes for cutting
things in general, and they will further figure that more of those votes would
be lost by cutting welfare (for example) than by cutting the USGS. They may
figure the typical voter will say "Look, they are cutting something (the USGS,
whatever that is)!" and may never recognize any troubles that may arise as
being due to that cut.
When the leadership of the majority party specifically mentions the USGS, I
figure one should prepare for the possibility (I see no certainty here) it will
be jettisoned (cuts would be a more typical Congressional answer, but Congress
has been shaken up lately).
Ask-a-geologist is a good example of how the USGS can make itself better
appreciated by that average voter. If it published and _marketed_ topo quads
on CD in a form that interfaced well with popular software, in a
reachably-priced all-U.S. set (I would prefer not to have to deal with one
expensive state CD here, another next time, another the time after that…), it
would go a longer way to getting the USGS noticed where it counts with
Congresspeople. I emphasize marketing because fewer people will pay attention
to it if they do not know it is there, have to search too hard to find it, take
too long to download it, or whatever.
–Doug