#PAR.EXE comments
21-Dec-94 10:05:19
Sb: #142992-#PAR.EXE comments
Fm: John K. Jordan 71174,711
To: Brick Eksten 74041,2043
Mr BE,
Thank you for your response! As a software developer myself, I'm especially
focused on things that could be changed, sometimes easily, that improve
productivity. Thanks for listening. (Try sending ideas to Microsoft and see
where they go. <g>)
>>destructive join, already there…
I've seen that in the PCREADME.TXT, but it said only to use it when the disk is
full and requred modifying the PAR.INI file. Even if the disk-full requirement
isn't the case, that wouldn't streamline operation except in rare cases.
Besides, there doen't seem to be any way to know if two files are contiguous.
Whether the destructive join of non-continuous files will take longer or
fragment the disk more is not an issue here.
Consider this: if I am arranging a series of segments into a single animation,
I have to manually and repeatedly Join, Delete, then Rename the TMP file. I
will process segments in an arbitrary order, taking a given length of time, and
leaving the disk in a given state of fragmentation when it is all done. I
don't really care what state the disk is left in, because my task is to create
a specific video presentation regardless of what goes on in the hardware and
software.
Think of what I'm suggesting from Mr User's viewpoint rather than from the
disk's viewpoint. The whole process would be streamlined if he could…
-Select the starting ANI
-Click the Join button
-Select all segments to be joined
-Specify in the dialog if this is to be a destructive join
-Click OK to perform the Join
For a destructive join
Ask for a file name, defaulting to the initial ANI
Join all segments, displaying progress
Delete all component segments
For a non-destructive join
Ask for a file name, presenting TMP as a default
(to get fancy here, present TMP01 if TMP is in use, etc.)
Join all segments, displaying progress
-Leave the highlight on the new file
Note that if the ANI file listbox had an option to redisplay the file list and
indicate which files are contiguous and capable of a non-fragmenting
destructive join, then I could perhaps use this informatino first to try to
plan and optimize my editing. However, the bottom line is I'm going to join
what needs to be joined, whether contigous or not. Operation somewhat like
that outlined above would simply let the computer do automatically what I now
have to do manually.
BTW, an extension of any ANI file listbox redisplay would be to allow a sorted
display by name, size, date, or unsorted (showing which are contiguous, perhaps
by separating non-contiguous files with something like "———-" in the
filename field)
>>there are quite a number of new features not outlined…
Great things to know. Let them out of their cages!
Is one of these features a stack of joins, or has that always been there? When
I click on Join again while the Join list box is already active, I seem to get
a stack of Join boxes, as evidenced by their unlayering as I click Cancel. (I
have not actually tried clicking OK on one of these stacks) If you do allow a
stack of joins, does it result in a single TMP file? Some layers can have a
single file name – what are they joined to? If this stack is a feature, it
would certainly seem to complicate the any potential destructive join
operation. Personally, I see limited use for such a feature, as it 1) can be
accidentally activated without any indication on the screen, and 2) hides a
pending operation from review. Again, I've been too chicken to try this, since
I have some things I on the drive that aren't backed up, so I may be way off
base here.
Thanks again for your attention!
JKJ