Suggestions for 3-D?
19-Feb-92 01:12:12
Sb: #16113-Suggestions for 3-D?
Fm: Wayne Cole 76370,621
To: John Pendergrass 76246,676
John,
I'm glad you mention Steve W.s new book – checkout section 1.1 Warning to
New Users. It confirms my opinion. If you want to invest time learning
you will eventually be rewarded. If you want to start maximizing
productivity early, try another package.
I used to think it was just me. But AmiExpo changed all that. I was in a
class with 11 other confessed Imagine owners. All had roughly equivalent
opinions. Very powerful, but it takes lots of time and effort to get what
you want from it due to the contra-intuitive nature of the program
organization, user interface and terrible documentation. In addition, if a
person uses Imagine only once or twice a month for a few objects/seconds of
Anims, he spends a fair amount of time 're-learning' the program becuase of
its obtuseness. Even some famous graphic/animation gurus in the Amiga
realm apart from Steve say that Imagine is based on a philosophy and
approach that did not make sense until they spend considerable time on the
phone with the creator getting inside his head to understand the
assumptions and space form which he came. After that, they claim, it was
easier to learn as they had a point of reference, yet it was still not
'intuitive' even with that knowledge.
I'm not being emotional or flaming. I have the program, I continue to
upgrade it, use it and buy about every book/video taped tutorial on the
program. After a year and a half with the program (no prior Silver
exposure – Sculpt 3D/4D only) I still don't 'get it' and have to labor
through things that are a snap in Lightwave, for example. Like, try
wrapping a map of the world onto a globe in Imagine. THen try to do it in
Lightwave. I gave up after 4 days about 6 – 8 hrs per day trying to do it
in Imagine. I accomplished it in 15 minutes in LW and in the next 4 days
did 3 different versions of earth fly-by/landing animations. Now, if I was
getting paid for producing, based on that experience it would be clear
where some extra room on my Hard drive would come from.
[ MORE ]