Suggestions for 3-D?
23-Feb-92 03:21:16
Sb: #16469-Suggestions for 3-D?
Fm: Wayne Cole 76370,621
To: Charles Blaquiere 76046,1756
Claigari2 at AmiExpo was $259. What sold me on it was when I asked this
guy sitting at an Ami with Caligari running to show me how to do this then
that etc. All the things that were difficult or obtuse in Imagine. He did
every one of them without hesitation or difficulty. Then I asked him to
convince me as to why I should invest in the package when I already owned
Sculpt, Imagine and Lightwave. His reply was, "Oh – I don't know anything
about that stuff – I just got Caligari two weeks ago and haven't played
with it much. I don't work for these guys. The guy you want to talk to
took a break. I'm just playing around until the next seminar starts…"
I ordered Caligari, needless to say.
As for the Imagine brush wrap I've tried it over and over everywhichaway.
It flat doesn't wrap without major holes AND distortions. As the manual
admits, like square wrapping paper around a basketball. There is either a
huge bunch of extra paper or you don't completely cover the ball. Anyway,
the real issue is even if it CAN be done (sorry, I'm taking a Missouri
attitude on this one) is that if it takes many hours or days to figure
something out in Imagine that can be done in Lightwave or Caligari without
looking at the manual, in the first try in five minutes, then I'd have to
say Imagine will be a commercial failure except with the 'cult of Silver'.
It doesn't have any extras the other programs are lacking that make it
worth that hassle.
BTW, Oran Sands had trouble with the same problem on Imagine. So imply
what you want about my mental capacity, I feel MUCH better knowing someone
of his calibre had trouble. (Also, I did a short Mensa test and did very
well on it. :^{&} <– Bronx cheer face.)
wmc