#PAR It's phenomenal
24-Feb-94 19:04:02
Sb: #86324-#PAR It's phenomenal
Fm: Paul Lind 71543,2104
To: John Ellis 72440,3046
John,
The Indy is an interesting piece of equipment. It has a phenomenal amount of
power, but like the Mac, it's GUI causes big headaches in the speed department.
Obviously the largest problem that SGI has faced in grabbing the "desktop"
market is Unix.
So many people in the Graphics industry are both hardware and software idiots.
I recently had a top salesman and his graphics guru for a world wide company
call me in the middle of the night to help them with a hardware problem. They
were trying to "clean" a hard drive off for a trade show the next day. Their
problem? They had tried for over an hour to get two directories off of the disk
and couldn't figure out how to do it. The directories, they told me, were dot
and dot dot. Quite obviously this level of expertise isn't exactly in line with
trudging around in Unix.
SGI has fixed this problem by creating Indigo Magic, for the most part even a
computer idiot can move around with relative ease. This has dramatically helped
in grabbing some of the high end desktop market.
Physically the Indy is a strong performer and with it's 1 meg cache, it is
faster than the Indigo2 on alot of 2D work. However, one of the biggest
problems is once again perception. The participants in the SGI market look at
it as a "stepchild" and the participants in the PC market think that it's going
to allow them to effectively compete with the high end animation houses. Both
assumptions are false. A good Indy is going to run $20,000 with an R4400/150,
24 bit graphics, 32 megs of ram, 1 gig drive, and 16 inch monitor. Add another
64 megs of ram for $9,000 and you're in business. $29,000 and you've got a baby
Indigo2 without 3D software. Sooooo…. all of a sudden there's once again a
big price difference between the two platforms. Outside of the gaming market, I
don't forsee it causing a tremendous change in the hardware market. But things
change quickly in today's world. At the SMPTE conference in November, Jim Clark
said that in less than two years it will cost less than $15,000 to purchase the
computing power that costs $150,000 today. That's quite a change. Almost any
hardware purchase that can't be paid off in less than 18 months is probably not
a wise decision. We depreciate everything over less than 18 months.
As to the use of the Indy, it's a very wise decision for those needing
processing power. For the price of a single 4 processor Onyx, one can put 10
Indy's on a network and more than double the computational power. This is
extremely useful for rendering. This is perhaps where the Indy's shine most for
the SGI based operations.
Sorry about the rambling. I'm tired. If you have further questions or more
specific questions throw them at me and I'll see what I can do.
Paul