CompuServe Thread

#Lightwave vs. 3DS

7 messages in this thread
#162209From: Bill FitchApr 1, 1995 9:12 PM
Hello I'm thinking of buying 3d studio in conjunction with a software program called Razzor Pro, which is a video editing package, and a Par board for video recording. I spoke to a guy in the industry about this combo of gear, he suggested waiting for a product from New Tech called Light Wave for the PC, he said the program was much better in every way. And he said the program was about 800.00 to 900.00 bucks. I'm quite confussed at this point. I like to also say that the program is not to be released until May of this year. He said that this program is used on the Amiga system, he goes on to say that 3d studio is not used much in Hollywood unlike the New Tech program. Help Please Bill Fitch
#162226From: Yost GroupApr 1, 1995 11:39 PM
Just to clarify things a bit… 3D Studio was the first non-SGI 3D animation system used in a feature film to do full-screen effects. Six minutes of (said) effects will be in Johnny Mnemonic, coming from TriStar/Sony in June. Lightwave has never been used to do full-screen feature film effects. Additionally, 3DS is used by some of the largest 3D animation production houses in Los Angeles, including Metrolight, R/Greenburg Assoc., Boss Films, RezN8, and Sony Pictures. I don't believe that Lightwave is being used at any of these facilities. Trying to keep the facts straight, – G
#162245From: Bill FitchApr 2, 1995 12:22 AM
Yost Group; Thank you for returning my message to all so quick. I glad that you where able to inform me of some things I didn't know. I'm still not sure what I should buy or not buy Regards Bill Fitch
#162991From: Brian S. SchmittApr 5, 1995 9:20 AM
Actually I think ElectricImage was the first non-SGI program to be used for full-screen CGI. It was used in Star Trek Generations. Brian Schmitt
#163000From: Yost GroupApr 5, 1995 10:13 AM
Good point… I think you're right — there was a little bit of EIAS CGI in Generations. – G
#162996From: Brian S. SchmittApr 5, 1995 9:37 AM
>I'm thinking of buying 3d studio in conjunction with a software program called >Razzor Pro, which is a video editing package, and a Par board for video >recording. I spoke to a guy in the industry about this combo of gear, he >suggested waiting for a product from New Tech called Light Wave for the >PC, he said the program was much better in every way. And he said the program >was about 800.00 to 900.00 bucks. I'm quite confussed at this point. I like to >also say that the program is not to be released until May of this year. He said >that this program is used on the Amiga system, he goes on to say that 3d studio >is not used much in Hollywood unlike the New Tech program. >Help Please >Bill Fitch Bill You must understand that you wil not get an unbiased opinion about Lightwave in the Autodesk forum as Autodesk is the distributor of 3D Studio. Both 3D Studio and Lightwave are very full-featured programs and I feel confident that you would be happy with either one. Before you purchase either one do ALOT of research. Find out what extra costs are incurred to get you where you want to be capability-wise. I'm sure you can find both NewTek and Autodesk dealers that will let you test drive the software before you buy it in there showrooms. Lightwave and 3D Studio have been used in quite a few Hollywood productions. Since the Yost Group has kindly posted some projects that 3D Studio has/is involved in, let me list some Lightwave projects. SeaQuest Hercules the Series Jurrassic Park Star Trek TNG (and spin-offs) Digital Man (in production) True Lies There are many others that I cannot recall at the moment. You shouldn't really base your decision on my or Gary's lists, but rather how well suited each program is to you tastes and production style. I hope this has helped you make a decision, although more likely it has only further confused you. Brian Schmitt
#163246From: Laurent LarsonneurApr 6, 1995 9:41 AM
While you are "punch-discussing" about the features of both programs, you don't use them. So why not try ? Laurent Larsonneur – Digital Studio SA