GAMMA GAMMA?
3 messages in this thread
This message is regarding Video and the Targa 32/64+ and gamma adjustment.
Only RGB and SVGA can be gamma adjusted with the Boxes to be able to
visually see Gamma Adjustment. In other words only through your SVGA
or RGB monitor will the boxes line up!
NTSC will not show proper Gamma alignment with the boxes. If you set
it to 1.0 where the boxes match, you have effectively disabled or
neutralized Gamma Correction in NTSC. You can check this by rendering
ADLOGO at 1.0 with Gamma on and then re-rendering with Gamma off.
They are identical.
If you set your framebuffer Gamma to 2.2 you will not see boxes that
match on your NTSC monitor but your NTSC will be gamma corrected. In
fact on your NTSC monitor the inner box will be bright.
RGB and SVGA will Gamma correct in that the boxes will match. I would
recommend that you make your gamma adjustments for either of these
two monitors or between 1.8 – 2.2 to suit your taste. While not
explicitly stated the Advanced User Guide does say "The standard
gamma value for NTSC video output is 2.2", it does not state however
how one is supposed to arrive at that, and the assumption has been
that by getting the boxes to match up you would have proper gamma
adjustment. This assumption is incorrect. This only works for RGB and
NTSC.
You also need to check your recording device to make sure it doesn't
gamma correct. Otherwise you run the risk of double correcting.
Thank You. This makes me feel better as I was about to spend half a day
switching monitors, gamma settings, and rendering test images just to match the
boxes. No need now.
I do, however, feel this strange inner hatred for little gray boxes.<g>
David
David – Your welcome, I think maybe a little too much has been made of these
little boxes as well. Basically it boils down to this, whatever you set your
framebuffer value to set your file input and file output to the same value and
everything will come out fine. A comfortable range is between 1.8 – 2.2 for
video. The NTSC side is already adjusted to compensate for gamma correction on
your NTSC monitor or Television monitor. This is a result of the NTSC
specification and is inherent in any NTSC signal. That's why your boxes match
up at 1.0 Hope this clarifys it for you. -JE