CompuServe Thread

#Compatibility Mac/PC

6 messages in this thread
#15324From: Dean J HollatzDec 4, 1991 3:58 PM
I'm trying to do some research regarding the compatibility between the various CD-Rom formats. I hear things like High-sierra standard, red book standard, Iso9660, and so on. I'm trying to get a better understanding of compatibility between the Mac and PC platforms. Is a CD-Rom drive Mac or PC specific? Or is it a matter of the same drive using a different interface? The other question would be about the disks themselves. Can I get a reference disk that would work on both Macs and PCs? I understand that a CD-Rom with executable code on it would be either Mac or PC, right? One final question. Is there a good periodical that would help me understand this stuff better? Thanks in advance. Dean There is 1 Reply.
#15340From: Matt SeitzDec 4, 1991 11:30 PM
Here's some analogies that might help you understand: 1) The term "Compact Disc" describes the physical media. Saying "Compact Disc" is like saying "3.5 inch floppy disc". 2) "CD-ROM", "Red Book", "CD-ROM XA" are all sector formats. They all use the same physical media ("Compact Disc") but the sectors are laid out differently. It's like 720K 3.5 inch floppy disks and 1.44M 3.5 inch floppy disks. Physically they are the same, but they have different sector formats. Some drives can use both sizes of disk, some only one or the other. Likewise, some Compact Disc players can only play digital audio Compact Discs (also called "CD-DA" or "Red Book", since the CD-DA specification has a red cover), some can read CD-DA and CD-ROM (CD-ROM is also called "Yellow Book", and still others can read CD-DA, CD-ROM, and CD-ROM XA. 3) ISO-9660 and High Sierra are volume formats. They determin where directories are placed on a disc and how they are formatted. This is similar to formatting a floppy disc. Both the Mac and the PC can use 720K 3.5 inch floppy disks. However they use different volume formats (Mac uses HFS, PCs use DOS). That's why the same physical floppy disk can be formatted on either computer, but once formatted it can only be used on that computer. ISO-9660 and High Sierra were designed to be portable volume formats. In order to read them on a Mac or PC, a special driver is loaded that translates between ISO-9660 and High Sierra and the computer's native disk format (HFS or DOS). A CD-ROM can use other volume formats besides ISO-9660 or High Sierra. Sometimes a CD-ROM is formatted using a computer's native format, such us HFS or SunOS. However, this means the disc can only be read by the computer that uses that native format. 4) There are no CD-ROM standards for data or program file formats. A program on a CD-ROM can only be executed by the operating system that the program was written for. 5) CD-ROM drives are not inherently computer specific, although their interfaces may be. For example, some drives require controllers that are only available as PC expansion cards. Others There is 1 Reply.
#15342From: Matt SeitzDec 4, 1991 11:38 PM
As I was saying… Other CD-ROM drives have a universal interface, such as SCSI. A SCSI CD-ROM drive can be hooked up to both a Mac and a PC at the same time. There is 1 Reply.
#15385From: Dean J HollatzDec 6, 1991 3:08 PM
Thanks for all the information. You just gave me more understandable information than I've bee able to dig up using the computer library that Ziffnet has. This may not be a fair question, and don't answer it if you don't want to, but. . . Do you live and breathe CD-Rom, or what? I've never had the chance to focus on single product families. Thanks again for the information. Hope you don't mind if I ask a couple more questions once I digested what you've told me. There is 1 Reply.
#15398From: Jerry IsdaleDec 6, 1991 10:07 PM
Matt did an excellent summary! Just to answer your last question, Look into "CD-Rom Professional". It is a Quarterly publication with a high cost ($86/year). I did however, find a card for it in one of the card-packs for a much cheaper rate ($35??) – Jerry Isdale
#15451From: Matt SeitzDec 8, 1991 12:29 PM
These days I do breathe CD-ROM. I'm senior technical support engineer for Meridian Data, maker of CD-ROM publishing, mastering, and networking equipment. So I spend a lot of time reading specifications and books on CD-ROM, making discs, working with mastering facilities and CD-ROM publishers, etc.