#dos v. amiga
3 messages in this thread
I know nothing of amiga but need the graphics. I have all dos
machines. If I buy an amiga, can I use my dos programs like amipro,
dtp, accounting, etc? Just how interchangeable is dos and amiga?
Are there programs that work on both? Am I wasting my time? I feel
like a stranger in a foreign country.
Marty,
The amiga OS is not at all compatible with msdos and msdos programs
will not run on an Amiga unless you have a DOS emulator, such as the CBM
Bridgeboard. The bridgeboard is basically a DOS box on a card which coexists
with the Amiga, but runs as a separate hardware and software machine. If you
want to run dos/windows programs rather than buy new software for an Amiga, you
are best off with a dos machine.
AmigaDOS is quite a different operating system from dos/windows or the
Mac. In the PC world the closest you will come to an operating system like the
Amiga's is OS/2 or Windowns NT. However, because dos machines are based on the
Intel processors and the Amiga is based on the Motorola processors, the
software written for one machine will not run on the other.
Marty,
you can use IBM programs on an Amiga (I'm living proof of that) but the
current solutions out there will end up either being very slow, or as
expensive as buying another PC entirely. The software solution is to use
CrossPC or one of the other software emulators. What these do is to read
each instruction within an IBM program and translate from what it does on
an IBM machine to what it should do on an Amiga. The two machines don't
speak the same language, so you are running a word by word translator.
Unfortunately, even on the accelerated machines, the programs run much
slower than a real IBM, and are only compatible at the XT (8088) level,
i.e. no Windows.
At the hardware level, you can add a board to the Amiga which is
essentially an IBM on a circuit board. While you can get acceptable
speeds out of it, by the time you add a SVGA card and the other cards you
might need, you are out some significant amount of cash.
I'm running both approaches here and while it does what I need to do,
i.e. maintain compatability with the University computers, I don't think
it's up to snuff for what you want to do.
There is a much better approach. Find out what programs that run on
the Amiga do what you need to do. Next, find out what file formats they
can save that your IBM can read as well. You may want to look at one of
the professional packages, such as Art Department Professional or
ImageMaster (??) that tranlate between formats. Once you have established
which programs you need to do the work you need to do, and which programs,
if any, you need to get to do the translations, go out and buy those
packages when you get the Amiga. If you buy an Amiga that has AmigaDOS
2.1, or better, with it, it can format, read, and write DOS diskettes for
you. So you're compatible at the disk level, so long as the data is
written in a manner that it understable to your IBM programs.
Make sure that you get a powerful enough Amiga to support the Amiga
programs you've selected. BTW, this is what I always recommend. Pick the
software first, then the hardware to run it. It'll save you grief in the
end.
The other recommendation I have is that you post a message similiar to
this, along with any other questions you may have, over in the AmigaArts
forum. I'm sure there are quite a few people that have had to bridge the
gap between the two worlds that hang out there. They are far more
knowledgable about what each program can do than I.
I hope this helps.
Brian
bjbart@watserv.ucr.edu