#Rendering in 512×486
18-Jan-95 21:22:36
Sb: #147570-#Rendering in 512×486
Fm: Don Landis 71673,3612
To: Jeffrey Lerer 74073,244
For 4 months I outputted the PAR via YIQ signals to the UVW-1800. The most
critical job I did was for the Jacksonville Chamber of Commerce. They needed a
very high quality animation recording because it was going to the big screen in
video. TWO 30 foot screens were used before an audience of several thousand.
The animation blended very well with the the rest of the betacam SP production.
My sample for the bid was up against an Abekas DDR and an SGI running
Wavefront. I was told the bidding was very close but I won. Quality was not
an issue for me because my PAR output to betacam SP met their quality
requirements. The only bidders that were disqualified due to quality were two
local companies that output to beta SP via the Toaster/Lightwave. It used Y/C
and was single framed with a BCD controller. I was told their output didn't
cut it due to bleeding color on the big screen. The actual way they described
it was the "Animation was out of focus in their audition tape."
Now, I don't know what your intended market is nor who you have to sell but IMO
there is no reason why, if you are very careful you can't go broadcast with the
PAR to beta SP. If the application is critical and you use pro SVHS I can
almost assure you you will be the looser in any bid where you are compared with
betacam, even though you are using Y/C. It's the recording process, Betacam
SP, there is no substitute! (Except for, maybe MII, but then you have to seek
out customers that can use MII <BG>) And, the price of betacam SP UVW is just
too good to pass up. As for generation loss. I can tell you that 5 component
generations of UVW betacam SP looks cleaner than 1st generation SVHS.
There were many here on the forum that have been very negative with respect to
the PAR and its use in broadcast. I decided to just ignore all of them and
start selling my stuff and getting on with my life. If I ran into a customer
that became nervous about the equipment without bothering to look at the output
I just refered them to my competitors with the Wavefront and the Abekas. I
decided these guys were probably too picky to bother with. There are just too
many good customers out there to be concerned about the clients from hell.