Amiga vs IBM & Mac
26-Feb-91 21:19:48
Sb: #6240-Amiga vs IBM & Mac
Fm: Steve Bennett/SYSOP 76702,1071
To: Syndesis 76004,1763
I dunno. I worry about the Mac. By giving people an "easy to use"
interface like the Mac GUI you tend to end up with a lot of people who are
using a computer without learning anything about how a computer really
works. This is fine on one side since it makes it faster for people to get
started, but it's also resulting in a lot of people who couldn't handle
some of the more trivial computer problems which come up.
A GUI is nice, and makes things easier, yes, but it's hardly necessary to
have one to use a machine. The vast majority of computer users have
actually never yet used a GUI and have gotten along just fine. And I
would, in general, feel better trusting one of those people to fix a
computer problem than one who has never touched a command line interface.
As a parallel, it's like learning Long Division. Why learn long division
when you have a calculator which can do it for you? Or perhaps more
ominously, why learn to *read* when you have a TV to tell you the news and
entertain you and tell you everything you need to know? It really does
worry me that the concept of "computer literacy" nowadays is limited to
being able to point and click with a GUI. Something to think about.
–>Steve Bennett