Forum unknown
· Audiophile
#Music Programs
3 messages in this thread
Can someone give me their opinion of the relative strengths of DMCS vs the
new Sonix? Anything either program does very well or any feature or bug that
is especially irritating? Which one has a better interface for composing from
the Amiga keyboard?
What do I want to use it for, you ask! Well, I would like a program that
would compose hit songs, get them copyrighted, distribute them to the right
major artist and keep track of my royalty income, while fully utilizing the
Amiga Intuition interface.
Barring all that, I would like to be able to enter music by playing from
something like a Yamaha DX21, be able to utilize fairly realistic acoustic
sounds (is this a function of the synth or program or both?) and print the
whole mess out.
Thank you, George Glines
George,
Well. Can't help with the program that prints money for you… I think that's
effectively what you were asking for. 8) As far as the rest of it is
concerned…
> I would like to be able to enter music by playing from something like the
Yamaha DX21…
DMCS allows you to enter music from a MIDI synth, but it's only in step time.
You can't play real time and have DMCS transcribe it; you need a sequence
recorder for that. One option, if you really like DMCS, is to purchase
SoundScape Pro MIDI Studio, use that for the actual recording, and run DMCS as
a module under SoundScape to do the transcription.
> … be able to utilize fairly realistic acoustic sounds (is this a function
of the synth or program or both?)
If you have a program which allows you to drive a MIDI device, you can have the
external device play your music for you. If the synthesizer has "fairly
realistic acoustic sounds", you will get fairly realistic acoustic sounds. A
sampler does an excellent job. So does a well programmed DX. If the program
utilizes internal sampled sounds, you can have the Amiga play your music for
you. At this point in time we're limited to four simultaneous voices and not
much bandwidth, but some of the samples I have here _are_ fairly good. If the
program allows both, you can have the best of both worlds. This lets the Amiga
handle lead lines or narrow chords, and bury itself in the mix behind the
external device(s) which handle the chord strata. This greatly improves the
perceived quality of the Amiga's voices. SoundScape or DMCS can do all these
jobs. Sonix I can't comment on, as I haven't gotten my review copy yet.
I know you don't want to wait, but there are reviews on these three programs
coming up in AC in a few months. Also, Music Studio has already been reviewed,
but I wouldn't suggest it for what you want to do.
If you have any other specific questions I'd be glad to answer them if I can.
George,
Well. Can't help with the program that prints money for you… I think that's
effectively what you were asking for. 8) As far as the rest of it is
concerned…
> I would like to be able to enter music by playing from something like the
Yamaha DX21…
DMCS allows you to enter music from a MIDI synth, but it's only in step time.
You can't play real time and have DMCS transcribe it; you need a sequence
recorder for that. One option, if you really like DMCS, is to purchase
SoundScape Pro MIDI Studio, use that for the actual recording, and run DMCS as
a module under SoundScape to do the transcription.
> … be able to utilize fairly realistic acoustic sounds (is this a function
of the synth or program or both?)
If you have a program which allows you to drive a MIDI device, you can have the
external device play your music for you. If the synthesizer has "fairly
realistic acoustic sounds", you will get fairly realistic acoustic sounds. A
sampler does an excellent job. So does a well programmed DX. If the program
utilizes internal sampled sounds, you can have the Amiga play your music for
you. At this point in time we're limited to four simultaneous voices and not
much bandwidth, but some of the samples I have here _are_ fairly good. If the
program allows both, you can have the best of both worlds. This lets the Amiga
handle lead lines or narrow chords, and bury itself in the mix behind the
external device(s) which handle the chord strata. This greatly improves the
perceived quality of the Amiga's voices. SoundScape or DMCS can do all these
jobs. Sonix I can't comment on, as I haven't gotten my review copy yet.
I know you don't want to wait, but there are reviews on these three programs
coming up in AC in a few months. Also, Music Studio has already been reviewed,
but I wouldn't suggest it for what you want to do.
If you have any other specific questions I'd be glad to answer them if I can.