#Morphed Letters
2 messages in this thread
> review should be written by someone with experience > because people
reading the review expect it, and the > magazine expects it.
I have jumped into this thread without reading the basic article, so I will
not get into commenting on anything but the sentence above –
I disagree strongly with you. It is far too easy for someone "with
experience" to forget about the steep learning curve of a product, or the
lack of support by the author. Based on _good_ reviews, I purchased
DAC[not very]Easy. I found the program to be impossible to use, the
documentation ommitted some significiant information and Tech support
wanted to charge me for each of the 3 calls I made [all refering to
omissions in the docs].
It _IS_ important that a reviewer spend enough time with a product to get
to know it, and to know how to use it. But years of experience can make
bad memories of learning a package fade.
I nose around this forum because I am interested in a future purchase of 3D
Studio – and I know that users often have a much more objective view of a
product than to journalists.
My two cents worth Rob
A good reviewer with experience will always look at a package from a new
user's and an experienced user's point of view. I think you're jumping to
a bit of a conclusion saying that an experience reviewer did that review.
An experienced reviewer would have caught that.
Just because a reviewer can understand what the program is about doesn't
mean that it automatically gets a good review. Quite the opposite. A
reviewer with experience will tear the thing apart and point out things
that someone with no experience wouldn't even think to look for.
Sorry about your experience though. Some reviewers (even some that have
been around a long time) seem to print glowing reviews about anything that
crosses their desks, and I think that's not being honest. It's not honest
for the readers, and it's not honest to themselves. It's best to remember
who steered you wrong with that program, and remember it next time you
read one of their reviews. I know that's what I do.
Steve