CompuServe Thread

#Framestores vs RGB

10 messages in this thread
#64132From: Barbara AndrewSep 11, 1993 3:28 PM
Can anyone educate me about the relative merits of framestores versus RGB files… In working in ToasterPaint, I make ongoing saves as RGB files because they contain more information. And when saving frames to disk from a Lightwave animation, I've saved them as images, because the files are usually much smaller than the standard 700K+ framestore size. When is it better to use framestores? Thanks Barbara
#64138From: THOMAS N. WHEELERSep 11, 1993 5:04 PM
Barbara, I can't really tell you whether it is best to save your images as framestores or as RGB files, although to my eye on my eqquipment framestores seem to afford a a bit better image quality than RGB files. However, it is worth noting that with ASDG's AdPro you can interconvert framestores and RGB (IFF) files. You might try comparing the same image saved as a framestore and as an RGB file using AdPro and reach your own conclusions as to which affords the optimum combination of image quality and storage size for your purpose. Tom
#64178From: Barbara AndrewSep 12, 1993 8:51 AM
Thanks, I'll do some experimenting. Barbara
#64155From: Jim SteeleSep 11, 1993 10:35 PM
Barbara, I think that the main use for framestores is in the switcher. The format is designed for fast loading. Jim
#64179From: Barbara AndrewSep 12, 1993 8:51 AM
Thanks for the info, Jim Barbara
#64246From: Jim S. RoofSep 12, 1993 9:15 PM
Barbara, With Lightwave 3.0 (if that's something that you are into) the framestores are saved in compressed format that is smaller than the compressed IFF format that LW saves out in rendering the frames. This certainly is an advantage for the animator. Also, the framestores are much faster to get to videotape due to the fact that they load in just about 2 seconds. I have begun to save all of my images in framestore format for these reasons. However, whenever Pegger is released I may switch to IFF saves that will be automatically compressed via JPEG routines residing somewhere in the OS. Just my $.02 worth. Jim Roof
#64164From: John GrossSep 12, 1993 12:25 AM
Framestores are video images that need to be saved when you want to load them from the Switcher. RGB files are computer images that should be used to save Works-in-progress in TPaint or when you want to use the image in another computer program. RGB files to save more info as they are "true'" color images. Framestores are video images and therefore using highly saturated colors (reds on yellow for instance) will cause color bleeding. With 3.0, Framestore images are compressed and will save more space than ther 2.0 722008 file size. JG
#64180From: Barbara AndrewSep 12, 1993 8:51 AM
So if I'm creating frams from Lightwave that I will compile into an anim using another program, it _does_ make sense to save them as RGB? Thanks for your help. Barbara
#64206From: Vance SchowalterSep 12, 1993 12:32 PM
Yes, RGB has more data information. Imagemaster R/t has a special feature called 'Trim' which allows you to save, smaller than normal, 24 bit RGB files without being lossy like JPEG. I think Ben Williams said you can save up to 70% on your hard drive by using 'Trim'. -= Vance =- Image Master Flying high on Black Belt Systems' Imagemaster!
#64227From: John GrossSep 12, 1993 3:37 PM
Absolutely. JG