CompuServe Thread

#Hidden cost

21 messages in this thread
#88837From: GaryAug 27, 1994 10:51 AM
This message is for any one thinking of buying the Emplant. On the outside it looks good. Four hundred dollars gets you a Mac II right? Wrong . 400.00 emplant 200.00 mac roms(most mac dealers tell you to get lost) 150.00 mac 800k drive 100.00 7.1 system software and manuals ???.?? AMIA interface —— 850.00 total you could go buy a used mac for that ! I've had my board over a month now and still no mac ! I thought I could go to the local Mac dealer and get the roms,they said no way only upgrades available to Mac owners.So I found a used mac II main board for 150.00. I took the roms out and put them in the emplant to dump the rom image. No luck, they would not dump.So I sent them to UU they did it for me(2 week wait).Great now I had everything right ? Wrong system 7.1 needs a mac 800k drive to install the software ( I found that out by calling the tech line they said I was one of three people that got 7.1 on 800k the Mac dealer said 7.1 comes on 800k only). I went to a mac shop and bought 6.0.7 software on 1.44k disk no problem reading that great! Oh no now I need to boot in 24 bit not 32 !What happened to all my memory ? Ten megs not enough ?You probably need close to 16 to get it to run mine keeps crashing. Well I have 620.00 invested so far I guess I'll buy the AMIA interface and Mac 800k drive so I can use this thing.It would have been nice to know up front about the requirements and had a better manual that spells things out without checking every page over and over and calling the very very very busy tech line all the time. This thing should be sold with everything you need so you don't have to get let down when you find out you have to buy something else. Like with AMIA, 800k disk drive and 7.1 software or 7.1 converted to something besides 800k. sorry about being long winded but it's been a long month.
#88871From: Andrew ChristieAug 27, 1994 7:06 PM
You have certainly had a tough time there Gary. But in all fairness, I must say that the Emplant is an excellent deal. I've never paid the prices you paid. I got the basic Emplant for $279. I don't need an 880k drive because I do one of two things first. I make sure the software is on high density disks, and if they are not, I make sure I buy them from a dealer who wouldn't mind transfering them for me, and as a last resort, I go to my friend who has a Mac and have him transfer the files. And, of course, if you don't need an 800k drive, you don't need AMIA. There are PLENTY of Mac roms out there if you are willing to do the search. And if the search can save you $100 or so, why not do it? I have 10 meg of ram in my A4000 and that is more than enough. I have enough memory to rum my Amiga and almost 9 meg left over for the Mac emulation. I don't see why you have a problem if you have 10 meg. Now, you know that if you are going to buy a computer or any parts for a computer, you have to do the research to make sure you get what you need at the right price. If I'm goning to buy a video board, I don't just pick up the phone and order the first one I see. I ask A LOT of questions, both to my friends and the computer dealers. Sure, it would be nice to have the dealers do all the work for us, but they are in business to sell computers, and if you say you want it, they are gonna sell it to you! You are responsible to make sure that you want it! And if you read the ad in AmigaWorld I think you will find that everything is in there, including AMIA. And finally, I see no reason to buy a used Mac even if I could get one for the price I paid for the emplant. I personally think it would suck having two computers taking up my desk space. And I will also be getting a 486DX in the same case for only $99 (and of course I have to pay for MS-Dos and Window, or anything else I want to run on it). Compare that to the price of buying an Amax and a 486 emulator seperate. Huge savings! My advice to you to put a little more time into you computer purchases before you order. Complaints about Emplant on Compuserve are almost nonexistant while praises for the product are the norm. The biggest complaint I've seen is the long wait for the 486 emulation.
#88879From: Wayne SteeleAug 27, 1994 11:40 PM
Whoever told you that System 7.1 is only available on 800K disks gave you false information. My local Mac dealer had no problem providing me a factory-original set of System 7.1 disks in high-density format. As for the ROM's, your right. They're not easy to find, and Apple won't allow dealers to sell them without first getting an older or defective set in return. The fact that you have to run in 24-bit mode to use System 6.0.7 is no fault of EMPLANT's. System 6 is not 32-bit clean and would crash miserabley if used in 32-bit mode. Apple knew this. That's why even a real Mac must us 24-bit mode for older versions of the OS. As for the memory problem, "Welcome to Macintosh." Macs need a good amount of memory to work effectively. There's certainly nothing the EMPLANT can do to fix this. And don't forget, there's some overhead needed for things like device caches, video drivers, and ROM images not to mention what the Amiga needs to stay running in that same 10MB. Running in 24-bit mode tightens the memory belt even more. Bottom line: Get more memory. You can never have enough! 🙂 Finally, I can tell you that AMIA and a Mac low-density drive are NOT required to get the emulation running. I did happen to buy these two items as well. But since I hardly use them, they seem more a luxury than a necessity. Obviously you've had a tough time getting your Mac emulation running. However, that doesn't mean it's a bad product. Since I knew exactly what was needed before I ordered an EMPLANT, I was able to get mine up and running within an hour of receiving it. My only complaint so far is that I can't track-down a problem with the "Sound Manager" extension and nobody will tell me if it's a know problem or something unique to my system (is somebody at UU reading these messages?).
#88906From: GE O'BrienAug 28, 1994 12:07 PM
I'm in the middle of getting everything together to install Emplant in a 2000. The reason I'm doing this is because the original 256 k MAC I have been using since 83 or 84 has been updated as far as it can go. It is now a MAC Plus running on system 6.07, and I want to run newer stuff 🙂 <<The fact that you have to run in 24-bit mode to use System 6.0.7 is no fault of EMPLANT's. System 6 is not 32-bit clean and would crash miserabley if used in 32-bit mode. Apple knew this. That's why even a real Mac must us 24-bit mode for older versions of the OS.>> Please educate me on a couple of things; 1. With an Emplant up and running w/sys 7.1 is it in 24 or 32 bit mode ? 2. Can I install sys 6.04 or 6.07 and run some of the older MAC programs and files I have on hand ? PS;<<(is somebody at UU reading these messages?).>> I hope so 😉 Sincerely GE "OB" O'Brien
#88911From: Wayne SteeleAug 28, 1994 1:13 PM
GE: The EMPLANT can run in either 24 or 32-bit mode (user selectable). I think an active MMU is required to use 24-bit mode, so EC030's are out. If you're gonna run System 7.1, then you'll want to use 32-bit mode. However, you can switch to 24-bit mode and boot with System 6 to run the older stuff. If you're asking if you can do both, the answer is yes. Wayne
#88918From: GE O'BrienAug 28, 1994 2:42 PM
Wayne; good news on being able to run either system thanks GE "OB" O'Brien
#88890From: Jonathan BlackwellAug 28, 1994 2:00 AM
Couple of things…. The Emplant board does not have to cost $400… it is cheaper mail order. I bought my Mac IIx ROMs for $25… they were being thrown out and I know lots of people that have found the same solution. I have an Amiga HD floppy and most new MAC software comes that way.. or on CD. The System 7.1 I would have to pay for if I were upgrading a real MAC anyway so I don't consider that part of the emulation cost. The end result is that for less than $500 I have a MAC Quadra 900 equivilant. Where can you find one of those for less than $500????
#88905From: GE O'BrienAug 28, 1994 12:07 PM
Jonathan, <<I bought my Mac IIx ROMs for $25… they were being thrown out and I know lots of people that have found the same solution.>> Could you put me on to some of those people who are throwing away MAC II ROMs…..? 😉 When on the Mac side can you pick up something to clipboard and import it to use over on the Amiga side ?? Could you give me a brief outline as how that works ?
#88915From: Wayne SteeleAug 28, 1994 1:35 PM
> "When on the Mac side can you pick up something to clipboard and import it to use over on the Amiga side ??" Yes. Just cut or copy on the Mac side, switch to the Amiga, and paste. There's also a method to transfer entire files or subdirectories between the two sides with great ease. It's pretty cool.
#88919From: GE O'BrienAug 28, 1994 2:42 PM
More good news, really glad to find out you can copy and paste across the two sides. Now, can you recommend a CD-ROM drive that will play both types of CD-ROMs (the ones for the Mac and the ones for the Amiga) (I hear that they are different ?) and how would an animal like that be tied up ? er-ah tied in 😉
#88925From: John LeonardAug 28, 1994 6:02 PM
You need the Apple CD300 – and software drivers for the Amiga side. Either generic to the 3.1 upgrade or from Xetec or AsimWare. The CD300 has just been replaced with the CD300E, which does not use a caddy to hold the CD, so the original CD300 can be found for very little money. What's more, it consistently beats all the opposition in speed tests! It comes with the necessary software for the Mac, although interestingly, whilst my Amiga 2000 can read CDs pressed to MAC standards, the (real) Mac that shares the CD-ROM can't read files from an Amiga CD-ROM. You might be interested in my SCSI setup – There is a computer at each end of the chain, and five SCSI devices in between: two hard drives on the Amiga and one on the MAC, a 230 Duo, a Syquest 44 and the Apple CD300. Provided that I'm careful about turn-on procedure (Syquest and CD-ROM first, the Amiga, then Mac,) all function perfectly well. The two computers recognise their own media and access them accordingly. A VGA switch lets me switch my monitor between the MAC and the Amiga, and of course the 386 Bridgeboard lets me access MS-DOS stuff on the rare occasions that I need to. The sole reason for having the MAC is that I need a portable computer and the Duo was a good deal – other than that, I find it annoyingly slow, and ridiculously heavy on memory. The OS needs over 3 meg of RAM, and programs like PhotoShop and Quark Express also eat up the silicon. I have 12 Meg in the Mac, and six in the Amiga. Guess which is faster!
#88967From: GE O'BrienAug 29, 1994 11:26 AM
John, Thanks for the info. I'm just researching things before I commit to a purchase. Sounds like you have a very interesting system configuration there. Thanks for shareing it with me.
#88927From: Wayne SteeleAug 28, 1994 6:13 PM
I have an NEC MultiSpin 3X hooked to the EMPLANT's SCSI port. I works fine with both the Mac and Amiga sides, I just can't use it from both at the same time (which makes sense). I use NEC's drivers on the Mac and AsimCDFS on the Amiga. I have had some minor glitches when using the provided "empscsi.device" to access the EMPLANT's SCSI port from the Amiga. It works well enough, but it's not totally reliable. Most of the Amiga CD-ROM's are in ISO-9660 format. This is also a popular format on UNIX and MS-DOS systems. The Mac, however, tends to have CD-ROM's that are standard HFS volumes. This isn't a problem. Most Mac and Amiga CD-ROM driver software can deal with both types. You shouldn't have any problems here.
#88968From: GE O'BrienAug 29, 1994 11:27 AM
Thanks for the info, we really appreciate your help. Wer'e just looking into all posibilities before we go out and buy one.
#89025From: Wayne SteeleAug 30, 1994 1:15 PM
No problem. I'm not an EMPLANT/Macintosh expert, but I've learned a lot about both during the past few weeks. Besides, we're all here to help each other out. 🙂
#89039From: GE O'BrienAug 30, 1994 3:23 PM
Wayne; Once again thanks, I appreciate the help. Now how about some more help. You know anybody who would sell me some old MAC II ROMs they might just have laying around. I need some reeeeel soon as our Emplant arrived but just a few moments ago. Guess what ? without the manual. So I understand one of Jim Cooks elves is sending me one. GE "OB" O'Brien
#89043From: Wayne SteeleAug 30, 1994 4:01 PM
GE: I have a pretty good relationship with the guys at our local Mac shop. I'll see if they can scrape-up another set. Mine came from an old Mac SE/30 that died. They gave me a bargain price. Anyway, I'll give them a call later today for ya! Wayne
#89052From: GE O'BrienAug 30, 1994 6:42 PM
OK…. Thanks Wayne GE "OB" O'Brien
#88942From: Jonathan BlackwellAug 28, 1994 9:05 PM
I bought a TEAC CD-50 that runs perfectly from both Amiga and MAC sides. -Jonathan // Amiga online via Autopilot. MAC Quadra 900 and \\// 486 emulation. E-Mail: jonathanb@delrina.com
#88969From: GE O'BrienAug 29, 1994 11:27 AM
Thanks for the info Jonathan, on both messages. I really appreciate the help. We'll follow up on those leads. Best regards GE "OB" O'Brien
#88941From: Jonathan BlackwellAug 28, 1994 9:05 PM
GE O'Brien- Call around to some of your local MAC repair shops. Many times, they just throw them away. With the latest software, you don't need the ROMs that support the HD floppy… the emulation will do it for you. Yes, the clipboard is shareable between MAC and Amiga sides… I can operate in a text editor on the MAC side (Teachtext) and copy the contents to the clipboard and immediately paste it into an editor on the Amiga side that supports the system clipboard.